BMAT 2011 · Question 17 · Assumption
SaveThe brain disease vCJD was caused by eating beef from cattle infected with BSE. Susceptibility to this type of disease amongst humans is associated with a particular gene. There are two variants of this gene – M and V, so there are three possible combinations that we can inherit – M-M, M-V and V-V. All infections so far in the UK have been in young people with the M-M combination. Most victims of a similar disease in Papua New Guinea also had the M-M combination and were also young, but a group who developed it later in life all had the M-V combination. Therefore the gene variants one inherits determine the incubation period for such diseases. So there will be two further outbreaks of vCJD, as those who consumed infected beef grow older.
Which of the following is an assumption underlying the above argument? 1 Most of the population have eaten beef infected with BSE. 2 Inheriting the V variant prevents infection with vCJD. 3 Inheriting the M variant is not necessary for susceptibility to vCJD.