BMAT 2017 · Question 17 · Identify Flaws
SaveWe often hear about childhood stars having breakdowns in later life. Celebrity gossip magazines regularly feature stories revelling in the decline of a once innocent and adored child actor into a troubled twenty-something going through painful relationship break-ups and battles with drug addictions. Their fate is inevitable given the moral bankruptcy of show business: the industry is steeped in sex, alcohol and drugs. Parents choosing to expose their children to these evils at such a vulnerable age must take the blame for their struggles with them in later life. Given the lasting damage, I would argue that it is actually child abuse to place a minor into such an environment. As part of our policy of child protection, it should be illegal to let your child work in show business.
Which of the following expresses a flaw in the above argument? 1 Break-ups and mental breakdowns do not occur only to childhood stars; they can happen to anyone. 2 Being adored as a child is not an adequate explanation for addictions or broken relationships in later life.